The Buffalo Trace barrel
This Friday's drop (Nov. 20) came out of a barrel that held Buffalo Trace bourbon — green Guatemalan coffee, a first for us in that wood. Here is what that means for the coffee, and what the wood had left to give it.
The short answer
This batch was aged in a barrel that previously held Buffalo Trace bourbon. The name marks the ancient buffalo paths that crossed the Kentucky River at what is now the distillery site in Frankfort, Kentucky. Distilling on that ground goes back more than two centuries. Bourbon enters the barrel at no more than 125 proof and sits in it for years. When it is emptied, the wood is still holding a great deal of what it took in. Our green Guatemalan coffee goes in next.
Whose barrel this is
Buffalo Trace is named for the land, not a date on a bottle.
For centuries, herds of buffalo wore a path across the Kentucky River near what became Leestown, just north of Frankfort. Hancock and Willis Lee established the settlement there in 1775. Distilling followed on that same ground; by 1870 Colonel E. H. Taylor, Jr. had purchased the site and christened it O.F.C. — Old Fire Copper — for the wood-fired copper stills he believed made the finest whiskey. George T. Stagg bought it in 1878. Under that name it was one of the few Kentucky distilleries permitted to bottle medicinal whiskey through Prohibition. The Sazerac Company returned it to family ownership in 1992, and in 1999 the site was rechristened Buffalo Trace Distillery. In 2013 it was named a National Historic Landmark.
Ours is a bourbon barrel. A first for us. Until this batch, we had not put coffee into wood that held Buffalo Trace.
We are not claiming any association with the distillery, and they have no involvement in what we make. We bought a barrel that held their whiskey, which is what the secondary market for used cooperage exists to do. But whose barrel it was matters to the coffee, and it is worth being specific rather than saying "bourbon barrel" and leaving it there.
Why an emptied barrel is not empty
Federal law requires bourbon to be matured in charred new oak barrels, and to enter them at no more than 125 proof.[1] One fill, one bourbon, and then the distillery owns a barrel it can never legally use for bourbon again. That rule is the reason a barrel like this one is available to us at all.
What arrives is not a dry container. Oak is porous, and across years of maturation the spirit works its way into the staves. Seasonal expansion and contraction drive liquid into the wood and back out again, over and over, for the whole life of the fill. By the time the whiskey leaves, the barrel has been thoroughly worked.
What the wood actually has to give
The flavors that come out of a barrel are not whiskey. They are oak, and they are the products of what heat did to the oak when it was toasted and charred before it ever held spirit.
| Compound | What it contributes |
|---|---|
| Oak lactones | Coconut, woody sweetness |
| Vanillin | Vanilla, from lignin broken down by the heat of toasting |
| Furfural, 5-methylfurfural | Caramel, almond, toasted grain |
| Eugenol, guaiacol | Clove, spice, a trace of smoke |
| Ellagitannins | Structure and grip through the middle |
There is residual spirit character in the wood as well, and it contributes. But the list above is where most of what you will taste comes from, and none of it is alcohol. We have written about that at length in a separate piece, including why the roast settles the alcohol question before the coffee is ever brewed.
We write these for the list.
New notes go out with the Friday drop — one email, 9:00 AM CT. Fewer than 100 bottles, and they're gone in minutes.
You're on the list.
Watch for the welcome email — moving it to your main inbox keeps Friday's link out of spam.
Why the coffee goes in green
Green coffee is dense, dry and porous. It has not yet been through the roast that will transform it, and in that state it takes up what it sits beside.
That porosity is the whole reason the method works. Green coffee has time to take on the oak slowly, and then a roast afterwards turns what it absorbed into something else entirely. The barrel does not deposit a finished flavor. It leaves material, and the roast makes something of it.
What it tastes like
The Guatemalan bean sits underneath, and the Buffalo Trace barrel pulls it somewhere else. Dry, woody oak sits alongside the coffee rather than on top of it, with a soft vanilla from the toasted staves that is never candy-sweet. Still coffee first, with the wood sitting around it rather than over it.
The thing we would most want you to know is that it still tastes like coffee. This is not a whiskey-flavored drink, and it is not sweetened.
How we would drink it
This is a concentrate. Treat it like a good bourbon or whiskey: cut with water, add a mixer (milk is an easy one), or drink it on the rocks.
Neat and cold, in a short glass, is how we would start. Over one large cube if the room is warm.
A small splash of cream pushes the oak and vanilla forward and turns the whole thing dessert-adjacent without any sugar involved.
It is 750ml and it is not sweetened, so it also works as the base of something else. We would just suggest tasting it on its own first.
References & further reading
- 27 CFR § 5.143(c), Table 1 — Standards of Identity for Distilled Spirits. Bourbon whisky must be distilled at 160° proof or less and stored in charred new oak barrels at 125° proof or less.
- Buffalo Trace Distillery, Frankfort, Kentucky — named for the historic buffalo crossing of the Kentucky River at Leestown (settled 1775); O.F.C. Distillery under E. H. Taylor, Jr. from 1870; George T. Stagg ownership from 1878; medicinal whiskey through Prohibition; rechristened Buffalo Trace in 1999; National Historic Landmark (2013). Company history and public sources.
- Mosedale, J. R. & Puech, J.-L. Wood maturation of distilled beverages. Trends in Food Science & Technology 9(3), 95–101 (1998).
You read this far. Get the link first.
Aged green in bourbon oak, roasted, cold brewed slow. Fewer than 100 bottles go up Friday morning and they don't last.
No spam. One email Friday at 9:00 AM CT.
You're on the list.
Watch for the welcome email — moving it to your main inbox keeps Friday's link out of spam.